Allstate vs. State Farm Car Insurance: A 2023 In-Depth Analysis for Your Ultimate Coverage Choice


In the ever-expanding realm of insurance options, choosing the right provider can be a daunting task. Allstate vs. State Farm stands out as two giants in the industry, especially when it comes to car insurance. This in-depth analysis, updated for 2023, aims to guide you through the intricate details of Allstate and State Farm, helping you make an informed decision for your ultimate coverage choice.

Allstate vs. State Farm: An Overview

If you’ve ever shopped for insurance, chances are you’ve encountered the names Allstate and State Farm. While both are renowned for their car insurance offerings, they extend their coverage to a myriad of other policies, including home, renters, business, pet, and life insurance.

Allstate – The Comprehensive Provider:

Allstate boasts an extensive range of policy offerings, making it a versatile choice for insurance needs. With a wide variety of endorsements, including commercial insurance, and an array of discounts, Allstate positions itself as a comprehensive provider. The company also provides helpful online tools, resources, and calculators to empower customers in making well-informed choices.

State Farm – The Agent Network Advantage:

On the other side of the spectrum, State Farm stands out with its massive agent network, totaling more than 19,000 agents nationwide. This network is particularly beneficial for those who prefer in-person interactions. While offering fewer discounts than Allstate, State Farm shines with two safe driver rewards programs, including one aimed at young drivers.

Comparative Analysis: Auto Insurance

When it comes to auto insurance, both Allstate and State Farm deliver exceptional coverage, each with its unique set of advantages.

Coverage Options:

  • Allstate and State Farm both provide personal liability, collision, comprehensive, medical payments, uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance, giving you a comprehensive set of coverage options.


  • While both companies offer various endorsements, Allstate pulls ahead with a slightly more extensive list. This makes Allstate the preferred choice for those seeking a high level of customization for their policies.

Rates and Discounts:

  • Car insurance premiums vary, and both companies offer discounts to help lower rates. Allstate, with its Drivewise program, and State Farm, with Steer Clear and Drive Safe and Save, provide safe driver rewards programs to incentivize responsible driving.

Comparative Analysis: Home Insurance

For those seeking home insurance, Allstate and State Farm present distinctive offerings, each with its own strengths.

Coverage Options:

  • Allstate and State Farm cover the basics with dwelling, other structures, personal property, personal liability, medical payments, and loss of use insurance. However, State Farm has stopped accepting new applications for home insurance in California as of May 27, 2023.


  • Allstate outshines State Farm in the home insurance endorsement department, offering 14 endorsements compared to State Farm’s five. This includes unique options like green improvement reimbursement coverage.

Rates and Discounts:

  • Allstate offers a more extensive list of discounts compared to State Farm. While both companies provide multi-policy and security system discounts, Allstate’s offerings are more diverse, providing potential savings for various criteria.

Comparative Analysis: Renters Insurance

If you’re in the market for renters insurance, both Allstate and State Farm have options, each with its own nuances.

Coverage Options:

  • Standard renters insurance policies from both companies cover personal property, personal liability, medical payments, and loss of use insurance.


  • While State Farm offers more endorsements for renters insurance, including earthquake insurance, Allstate provides solid coverage with a slightly fewer number of options.

Rates and Discounts:

  • Both companies offer limited discounts for renters insurance. State Farm, however, has an edge with more endorsement options, allowing for better customization.

Comparative Analysis: Commercial Insurance

For businesses in need of insurance coverage, Allstate and State Farm offer a range of options.

Coverage Options:

  • Both companies cover commercial auto insurance, property insurance, liability umbrella insurance, business owner’s policy (BOP), and more. State Farm, however, includes workers’ compensation, surety and fidelity bonds, builder’s risk insurance, and farm and ranch insurance.


  • State Farm and Allstate provide similar add-on coverages for commercial insurance. The extent of coverage varies, and businesses should carefully consider their unique needs.

Rates and Discounts:

  • Commercial insurance rates depend on various factors unique to each business. Both Allstate and State Farm do not offer specific discounts for commercial insurance, but businesses may qualify for a multi-policy discount.

Comparative Analysis: Other Insurance Products

Beyond the primary insurance types, both Allstate and State Farm offer an array of additional policies.

Other Insurance Products:

  • Motorcycle, boat, classic car, RV, off-road vehicle, condo, landlord, personal articles, manufactured home, farm and ranch, identity theft, individual life, health, pet medical, disability, flood insurance, and more are available from both providers, with slight variations in coverage.

Customer Service and Claims:

Customer Service:

  • Both Allstate and State Farm offer various customer service options, including phone, online, email, and in-person support. Allstate has an edge with helpful online tools, while State Farm stands out with its extensive agent network.

Claims Processing:

  • The claims process is similar for both companies, involving online and mobile app submissions for auto, home, and renters insurance claims. For other types of policies, a direct call to the company is necessary.

Customer Satisfaction:

  • Reviews indicate positive experiences with both companies, emphasizing efficient claim handling, prompt roadside assistance, and useful mobile tools. Negative reviews often revolve around claim payout dissatisfaction and difficulties in agent communication.

Getting a Quote:

Quote Process:

  • Both Allstate and State Farm offer online quotes, allowing you to conveniently explore coverage options. Whether online or over the phone, the process is quick, requiring basic personal and policy-related information.

Agent Rapport:

  • Building rapport with an agent is crucial, considering the agent’s role in providing personalized service. If the initial interaction doesn’t establish a connection, both companies allow customers to find another agent.



  • Wide variety of endorsements for most policies, including commercial insurance
  • Great discounts for homeowners insurance
  • Helpful online tools, resources, and calculators


  • Only offers a few renters insurance discounts
  • Fewer agents than State Farm, with a network of about 10,100



  • Network of more than 19,000 agents around the country
  • Two safe driver rewards programs, including one aimed at young drivers
  • One of the few providers that offers roof-related discounts for home insurance


  • Very few home insurance endorsements
  • Car insurance isn’t sold in every state
  • Doesn’t offer 24/7 customer service


In the realm of insurance, the choice between Allstate and State Farm ultimately depends on your individual preferences, coverage needs, and the level of customization you seek. This comprehensive analysis aims to equip you with the knowledge needed to make an informed decision, ensuring your insurance choice aligns seamlessly with your unique requirements in 2023.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Allstate and State Farm Car Insurance

What types of insurance does Allstate offer?

Allstate offers a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, renters, business, pet, and life insurance.

How does State Farm’s agent network work?

State Farm boasts a large network of over 19,000 agents across the country. These agents provide in-person assistance, making it convenient for customers who prefer face-to-face interactions.

What endorsements does Allstate offer for home insurance?

Allstate provides an extensive list of endorsements for home insurance, including unique options like green improvement reimbursement coverage.

Can I customize my insurance policy with Allstate?

Yes, Allstate allows customers to customize their policies with various endorsements, providing flexibility in coverage options.

Does State Farm offer discounts for safe driving?

Yes, State Farm offers safe driver rewards programs, including Steer Clear for drivers under 25 and Drive Safe and Save for drivers over 25.

What discounts are available for car insurance with Allstate?

Allstate offers a range of discounts, including those for accident-free driving, defensive driving courses, responsible payment history, and more.

Are there discounts for multi-policy coverage with both companies?

Yes, both Allstate and State Farm offer multi-policy discounts, allowing customers to save by bundling different insurance policies.

Can I get a quote online for both Allstate and State Farm?

Yes, both companies provide online quoting services, allowing customers to explore coverage options and get quotes conveniently.

How is the customer service of Allstate and State Farm?

Both Allstate and State Farm offer various customer service options, including phone, online, email, and in-person support. Customer reviews generally highlight positive experiences.

What should I consider when choosing between Allstate and State Farm?

When choosing between Allstate and State Farm, consider factors such as coverage needs, endorsement options, discounts, and the level of personal interaction you desire. This comprehensive analysis can help you make an informed decision based on your unique preferences.

Leave a Comment